AudiologyOnline Phone: 800-753-2160


Starkey - Edge - October 2024

Worker's Comp and Hearing Aid Benefit

David M. Lipscomb, PhD

December 6, 2004

Share:

Question

I have a patient who filed a claim for occupational hearing loss in the State
of Washington. The claim was allowed, but because the ENT stated that
there was little benefit from amplification (mild, high-frequency loss),
he has been denied hearing aids. Any suggestions for articles/proof that I might use to follow-up with the state?

Answer

This touches on the age-old question regarding what I call data-free opinions ventured by professional persons. Physicians and audiologists carry a great deal of weight with compensation entities -- especially when the recommendation saves the comp program money. In this day and time, it is unwise and inappropriate to guess whether amplification will be beneficial based simply on pure tone audiometry. In former times (when I was a practicing clinical audiologist) mild hearing impairments were difficult to satisfy with amplification and hearing aid devices were woefully lacking in the adjustments necessary to accommodate the lesser impairments. Historically, noise-induced impairments are among the most difficult to fit. Those problems no longer exist with modern amplification units.

I am firmly convinced that the final arbiter of decisions on the propriety of amplification is the hearing aid evaluation. Without information on patient performance with amplification, we are left to guesswork. While the physician's opinion might be confirmed with further testing, it will never be known whether the patient, in fact, benefits adequately.

My area of study is hearing conservation and the development/evaluation of programs. Thus, I confess to limited current knowledge of the hearing aid literature -- particularly as it relates to mild impairments. I have three suggestions:

  1. A PhD dissertation by Dennis Earl (U. of Tennessee) discovered that persons with hearing within the "normal" range (no greater than 20 dB HL for any hearing test frequency) could be separated into two groups: "normal-normals" and "abnormal-normals". This separation was first determined by a questionnaire and was then confirmed by testing for release from masking. The importance of this finding is that there are folks who do not perform at all normally, even though they would be considered "within the normal range".

  2. The work of Dr. Fred Bess and colleagues (Vanderbilt University) has illuminated many of the problems of mild impairment, particularly in children. I invite you to search for his studies, or contact Dr. Bess at the Bill Wilkerson Speech and Hearing Center in Nashville, TN.

  3. In the January issue of JAAA, on p. 6 begins an article by a group in The Netherlands regarding mild hearing impairment and auditory processing tests. Of importance in this report, in addition to the data they present, is the considerable list of references at the end of the article.
To reiterate: literature aside, clinical sense dictates that no estimate of facility with amplification should be ventured without first trying amplification on the person. I, too, live in Washington and have found the Labor and Industries professionals to be responsive to a petition for hearing aid evaluation prior to final determination of the need for amplification.

Dr. David M. Lipscomb obtained his Ph.D. at the University of Washington in 1966. He began his career as a clinical audiologist and professor of audiology. Throughout most of his professional life, he has participated as a consultant in a wide range of subjects. In 1987, Dr. Lipscomb left academia and entered full-time consulting. This avenue of professional service has included setting up hearing conservation programs, evaluating such programs, consulting with community and governmental entities, investigating collisions involving acoustical warning signals, and participating in litigation as an expert witness.


David M. Lipscomb, PhD

President, Correct Service, Inc.,

Dr. Lipscomb served as professor of Audiology in the Department of Audiology and Speech Pathology for the University of Tennessee.  In addition to teaching mostly graduate level classes, he conducted research and was Director of the department's Noise Research Laboratory.  Since 1966, he has qualified in courts of law as an expert in the field of Audiology.  He has testified in hundreds of depositions and more than 100 trials. None - there are no conflicts of interest and I have nothing to disclose


Related Courses

Innovative Audiologic Care Delivery
Presented by Rachel Magann Faivre, AuD, Lori Zitelli, AuD, Heather Malyuk, AuD, Ben Thompson, AuD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Rachel Magann Faivre, AuDLori Zitelli, AuDHeather Malyuk, AuDBen Thompson, AuD
Course: #38661Level: Intermediate4 Hours
  'informative'   Read Reviews
This four-course series highlights the next generation of audiology innovators and their pioneering approaches to meeting unmet audiologic needs in their communities and beyond. This peer-to-peer educational series highlights researchers, clinicians, and business owners and their pioneering ideas, care delivery models, and technologies which provide desperately needed niche services and audiologic care.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Concierge Mobile Audiology: Creating and Sustaining a Successful and Rewarding Practice
Presented by Rachel Magann Faivre, AuD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenter

Rachel Magann Faivre, AuD
Course: #38408Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'A lot of good details and visual examples, resources, etc'   Read Reviews
Concierge mobile audiology provides an alternative work environment to working in a traditional clinic. This course provides steps to creating and implementing a successful concierge mobile clinic. This course is part of a four-course series, Destroying the Box: Innovative Audiologic Care Delivery which highlights the next generation of audiology innovators and their pioneering approaches to meeting unmet audiologic needs in their communities and beyond.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

20Q: Consumer Reviews Offer Hearing Care Insights
Presented by Vinaya Manchaiah, AuD, MBA, PhD
Text/Transcript
AudiologyOnline

Presenter

Vinaya Manchaiah, AuD, MBA, PhD
Course: #36108Level: Introductory2 Hours
  'Appreciated information about online reviews relevant to Audiology'   Read Reviews
This engaging Q & A course discusses research about online consumer reviews in hearing healthcare. The discussion includes what audiologists and hearing care professionals can learn from reviews in order to deliver the best possible patient experience and positive outcomes with hearing care.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Beyond Bedside Manner: Insights on Perfecting the Patient Experience in the Era of OTC
Presented by Brian Taylor, AuD, Shareef Mahdavi
Audio
Signia

Presenters

Brian Taylor, AuDShareef Mahdavi
Course: #38160Level: Intermediate0.5 Hours
  'AMAZING! I bought the book before you even finished the introduction'   Read Reviews
Shareef Mahdavi is a patient experience expert. In this podcast he shares several valuable insights on how to create more remarkable and engaging patient experiences, designed to set clinicians apart from OTC retailers.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Optimize your Practice with Ready-to-Wear Solutions
Presented by Jessica Dancis
Recorded Webinar
Sennheiser Hearing

Presenter

Jessica Dancis
Course: #39185Level: Intermediate0.5 Hours
  'Good, positive information'   Read Reviews
Discover how, through leveraging Sennheiser early-entry hearing devices, you can broaden your offering, tap into new consumer markets, and evolve into a more comprehensive hearing healthcare provider. We will demonstrate how the integration of ready-to-wear hearing devices can not only create new revenue streams for your practice but also fortify your relationships with existing patients.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.