Question
What are your thoughts on doing only warm or cold irrigations,not all 4? If there is symmetry after same temperature testing in both ears, do you stop there?
Answer
There are a few differing opinions on this subject. There is general agreement that a symmetrical monothermal test is very predictive of a normal bithermal test (about 97 to 99% predictive when using a narrow asymmetry value of 5% interaural difference (IAD)). One study used warm stimulus, another used both warm and cool and determined that cool was a better stimulus for a monthermal caloric screening test. The main problem with a monothermal screening is the high false positive rate. The most recent study to look at this found that 78% of patients failing the above 5% IAD had a normal bithermal test.
Bottom line: If for some reason (nausea, patient refusal, etc) you can't complete all four irrigations, and the monothermal responses are within 5% symmetry, you are likely to be okay (assuming your exam is otherwise normal). There is very little downside to completing all four irrigations, and the accuracy of your test is improved by doing so. Keep this in mind: Even with a 97% predictive value, 3 out of 100 patients will be misdiagnosed taking this shortcut.
Alan Desmond, Au.D is the director of Blue Ridge Hearing and Balance Clinic in Bluefield and Princeton, WV. Thieme Medical Publishers released his book Vestibular Function: Evaluation and Treatment in April 2004. He can be reached at Alan@earexperts.com
Alan L. Desmond, AuD
audiologist and author
Related Courses
1https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/guide-to-bithermal-caloric-testing-815A Guide to Bithermal Caloric TestingThe purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyAudiologyOnlinewww.audiologyonline.comA Guide to Bithermal Caloric TestingThe purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.815OnlinePT60M
The purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.
2https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/guide-to-bithermal-caloric-testing-36752A Guide to Bithermal Caloric TestingThe purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyAudiologyOnlinewww.audiologyonline.comA Guide to Bithermal Caloric TestingThe purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.36752OnlinePT60M
The purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.
3https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/utilization-ics-impulse-for-oculomotor-33756Utilization of the ICS Impulse for Oculomotor Assessment in VideonystagmographyThis presentation describes the use of the ICS Impulse for the assessment of the oculomotor pathway in patients with vestibular pathology. Specific attention will be given regarding which tests analyze similar neurological pathways. The use of a different protocol using the ICS goggles compared to using the traditional VNG protocol will be explored.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyAudiologyOnlinewww.audiologyonline.comUtilization of the ICS Impulse for Oculomotor Assessment in VideonystagmographyThis presentation describes the use of the ICS Impulse for the assessment of the oculomotor pathway in patients with vestibular pathology. Specific attention will be given regarding which tests analyze similar neurological pathways. The use of a different protocol using the ICS goggles compared to using the traditional VNG protocol will be explored.33756OnlinePT60M
This presentation describes the use of the ICS Impulse for the assessment of the oculomotor pathway in patients with vestibular pathology. Specific attention will be given regarding which tests analyze similar neurological pathways. The use of a different protocol using the ICS goggles compared to using the traditional VNG protocol will be explored.
4https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/addressing-fall-risk-pt-ot-38144Addressing Fall Risk: PT, OT, and Audiology Assessment and Intervention, presented in partnership with Salus UniversityMultidisciplinary assessment and intervention of individuals at risk of falls is crucial in identifying functional and diagnostic factors as well as effective rehabilitation and prevention of future falls. This series identifies areas of collaboration and supportive information-sharing strategies between professions who commonly see individuals who fall and are likely to be injured due to a fall.auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyAudiologyOnlinewww.audiologyonline.comAddressing Fall Risk: PT, OT, and Audiology Assessment and Intervention, presented in partnership with Salus UniversityMultidisciplinary assessment and intervention of individuals at risk of falls is crucial in identifying functional and diagnostic factors as well as effective rehabilitation and prevention of future falls. This series identifies areas of collaboration and supportive information-sharing strategies between professions who commonly see individuals who fall and are likely to be injured due to a fall.38144OnlinePT180M
Multidisciplinary assessment and intervention of individuals at risk of falls is crucial in identifying functional and diagnostic factors as well as effective rehabilitation and prevention of future falls. This series identifies areas of collaboration and supportive information-sharing strategies between professions who commonly see individuals who fall and are likely to be injured due to a fall.
5https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/contemporary-concepts-in-pediatric-vestibular-35586Contemporary Concepts in Pediatric Vestibular Assessment and Management, presented in partnership with Seminars in HearingThis 5-part webinar series is focused on the growing evidence of the need for pediatric vestibular evaluation, as well as the availability of successful treatment options for children. Guest editors, Dr. Devin McCaslin and Dr. Jennifer Christy along with a team of leading experts will present on select articles from a recent issue of the journal Seminars in Hearing (Issue 03 · Volume 39 · 2018).auditory, textual, visual129USDSubscriptionUnlimited COURSE Access for $129/yearOnlineOnlyAudiologyOnlinewww.audiologyonline.comContemporary Concepts in Pediatric Vestibular Assessment and Management, presented in partnership with Seminars in HearingThis 5-part webinar series is focused on the growing evidence of the need for pediatric vestibular evaluation, as well as the availability of successful treatment options for children. Guest editors, Dr. Devin McCaslin and Dr. Jennifer Christy along with a team of leading experts will present on select articles from a recent issue of the journal Seminars in Hearing (Issue 03 · Volume 39 · 2018).35586OnlinePT300M
Presented by Sharon Cushing, MD, FRCSC, Katheryn Bachmann, PhD, Violette Lavender, AuD, Jennifer B. Christy, PhD, PT, Steven M. Doettl, AuD, PhD, Devin L. McCaslin, PhD, Kristen L. Janky, PhD, Amanda I. Rodriguez, PhD, AuD
AudiologyOnline
Presenters
Sharon Cushing, MD, FRCSCKatheryn Bachmann, PhDViolette Lavender, AuDJennifer B. Christy, PhD, PTSteven M. Doettl, AuD, PhDDevin L. McCaslin, PhDKristen L. Janky, PhDAmanda I. Rodriguez, PhD, AuD
This 5-part webinar series is focused on the growing evidence of the need for pediatric vestibular evaluation, as well as the availability of successful treatment options for children. Guest editors, Dr. Devin McCaslin and Dr. Jennifer Christy along with a team of leading experts will present on select articles from a recent issue of the journal Seminars in Hearing (Issue 03 · Volume 39 · 2018).
