AudiologyOnline Phone: 800-753-2160


Cochlear Osia System - June 2024

Consensus for Normal Thresholds for BOA and VRA

Roanne Karzon, PhD, CCC-A

July 30, 2007

Share:

Question

What is the consensus on pediatric behavioral hearing testing (4 months+) regarding the upper limit of normal? In other words, what is defined as a "Normal range" of response for young infants for Behavioral Observational Audiometry? I have read conflicting literature on this, some of which suggests that you should expect infants to respond similarly to adults if they have normal hearing, at 0-15 dB. Elsewhere, I have read that you should expect elevated thresholds for normal hearing infants.

Answer

The consensus in pediatric audiology is that normal hearing level for the audiometric frequencies and speech awareness threshold for young infants is < 15 dB HL.  For young infants there are two methods for behavioral hearing assessment.  The first, and less reliable/valid, is behavioral observation audiometry (BOA).  For BOA, stimuli are presented and trained observers watch for a time-locked response to the sound, such as eye-widening or cessation of activity.  BOA responses are not conditioned and will occur at varying sensation levels above threshold.  Since the advent of auditory brainstem response audiometry (ABR), this technique is rarely used in clinic to attempt to define hearing loss.

The second technique is visual reinforcement audiometry (VRA).  For VRA, the infant is conditioned through operant conditioning techniques to turn toward the sound stimulus.  When the child turns toward the sound stimulus, the visual reward is typically the lighting of a three dimensional toy animal or the lighting and animation of the toy animal.  Much research has gone into VRA and if the infant is well conditioned (i.e., good stimulus-response control), responses may be obtained at levels very close to true threshold (within 5 to 10 dB).  To obtain the maximum number of threshold searches within a clinical session, most audiologists do not test below either 10 or 15 dB HL There is no point in spending valuable attention span  jockeying for a threshold response of 0 or 5 dB HL.  If the response is normal for the test stimulus (i.e., < 15 dB HL), it is better to move to another frequency or stimulus to map out a greater portion of the audiogram.

With respect to your question about age, most infants who are at least 6 months of age with good head/neck/trunk control and normal cognition can be trained to perform VRA.  As you reduce age level to 5 or 4 months of age, fewer normally developing infants can be successfully conditioned and/or can maintain performance levels long enough to produce sufficient threshold searches to justify a clinical test session.  When stimulus-response control is not fully achieved or maintained, the infant will not respond to threshold levels. In these cases the audiologist records a minimum response level (MRL), which represents the “best” response obtained to the stimulus, rather than a threshold estimate.  In our experience, many infants are interested in speech as a stimulus and readily respond down to a level of 15 dB HL or close to true threshold (in the case of hearing loss).

However, when the audiologist presents pure tones, narrow-band noise or warble tones, the stimulus is intrinsically less interesting and they may respond only to elevated sensation levels. 

For infants with special needs, either delayed cognition or motor control, the age at which they can be successfully conditioned for VRA increases.  Thompson, Wilson and Moore (1979) revealed that VRA was successful for 88% of low-functioning infants and children over 9 months of age.  Wilson, Folsom and Widen (1983) found that 80% of children with Down syndrome were testable via VRA by 12 months of age. 

Successful conditioning and maintenance of conditioning has been studied and the principles of VRA administration need to be integrated into the test session to obtain optimal results.   The following references are selected to assist the reader in establishing the best practices for VRA.

Selected References

Dievendorf, Allen O. and Gravel, Judith S.(1996) Behavioral Observation and Visual Reinforcement Audiometry. In S.E. Gerber (ed.), The Handbook of Pediatric Audiology, chapter 4, 55-83.Gallaudet University Press.

Renshaw, J.J. and Diefendorf, A. O. (1998) Adapting the Test Battery for the Child with Special Needs.  In F. H. Bess (ed.), Children with Hearing Impairment: Contemporary Trends, chapter 7, 83-104, Vanderbilt Bill Wilderson Center Press.

Thompson, G. Wilson, R.W. and Moore, J.M. (1979)  Application of visual reinforcement audiometry (VRA) to low-functioning children.  Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 44(2), 80-90.

Wilson, W.R., Folsom, R.C., and Widen, J.E. (1983) Hearing impairment in Down’s syndrome children.  In G. Mencher and S. Gerger (eds), The multiply handicapped hearing impaired child.  New York:  Grune and Stratton.


Roanne Karzon, PhD, CCC-A

Roanne Karzon, Ph.D. CCC-A has worked in pediatric audiology for 23 years. She is manager of the audiology and cochlear implant programs at St. Louis Children's Hospital and past president of the Missouri Academy of Audiology. Her clinical and research interests are in the area of early identification of hearing loss including newborn hearing screening and initial diagnostic assessment.  


Related Courses

Improving EHDI with CAEPs: Clinical Assessment of the Cortical Auditory Evoked Potential in Children with Hearing Loss
Presented by Elizabeth Musgrave, AuD, CCC-A
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenter

Elizabeth Musgrave, AuD, CCC-A
Course: #31492Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very pragmatic presentation regarding the clinical applications of cortical auditory evoked potentials and the value in using this procedure for the assessment of infants and children'   Read Reviews
This course will provide an overview of cortical auditory evoked potentials, current research, benefits and limitations to using CAEPs in a busy clinic, and several case studies.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

A New Evidence-Based Approach for Hearing Screening of Preschool and School Age Children
Presented by James Hall, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Grason-Stadler (GSI)

Presenter

James Hall, PhD
Course: #39694Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Sophisticated and high-level course-- challenging and informative'   Read Reviews
The course begins with a summary of the limitations of pure tone hearing screening followed by a review of the rationale for objective hearing screening of younger school age and preschool children. Most of the course is devoted to a description of critical steps in the development and implementation of an evidence-based efficient and effective hearing screening program for children of all ages.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Pediatric Grand Rounds: Embracing the Unexpected, in partnership with Phoenix Children’s Hospital
Presented by Deborah Flynn, AuD, CCC-A, Allie Sayer, AuD, CCC-A, Christina Dubas, AuD, CCC-A, Rachel Worcester, AuD, ABA-C, Caroline Sabatino, AuD, CCC-A, Robert Fanning, AuD, CCC-A, Wendy Steuerwald, AuD, CCC-A
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Deborah Flynn, AuD, CCC-AAllie Sayer, AuD, CCC-AChristina Dubas, AuD, CCC-ARachel Worcester, AuD, ABA-CCaroline Sabatino, AuD, CCC-ARobert Fanning, AuD, CCC-AWendy Steuerwald, AuD, CCC-A
Course: #39703Level: Advanced1.5 Hours
  'Variety and depth of information'   Read Reviews
This pediatric grand rounds presentation presents case studies of six patients with hearing concerns. Collaboration, evidence-based practice, and innovation are used to obtain the best outcomes.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Pediatric Grand Rounds: Beyond the Basics to Maximize Outcomes, presented in partnership with Nationwide Children’s Hospital
Presented by Gina M. Hounam, PhD, Holly T. Gerth, AuD, Lauren Durinka, AuD, Christine Schafer, AuD, Alecia Jayne, AuD, CCC-A, Ursula M. Findlen, PhD, Caitlin Cummings, PhD, CCC-SLP, Lauren Y. Yoshihiro, MS, CCC-SLP
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Gina M. Hounam, PhDHolly T. Gerth, AuDLauren Durinka, AuDChristine Schafer, AuDAlecia Jayne, AuD, CCC-AUrsula M. Findlen, PhDCaitlin Cummings, PhD, CCC-SLPLauren Y. Yoshihiro, MS, CCC-SLP
Course: #39706Level: Advanced1.5 Hours
  'I love ground rounds'   Read Reviews
This Grand Rounds session features audiologists and speech pathologists who specialize in diagnosing and managing pediatric patients. During this course, a panel of speech and audiology professionals shares 5 clinically applicable cases that helped them grow and innovate their clinical practice. The importance of evidence-based care is highlighted to achieve the best outcomes for pediatric patients.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Giving Children a Voice in Their Hearing Care Appointments: Using Ida Institute’s My Hearing Explained for Children in Your Daily Practice
Presented by Natalie Comas, BSpPath, LSLS Cert. AVT
Recorded Webinar
Oticon

Presenter

Natalie Comas, BSpPath, LSLS Cert. AVT
Course: #37407Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Loved the tool!'   Read Reviews
How can pediatric hearing care professionals meet the challenge to support the 1989 United Nations “Convention on the Rights of the Child” rights in a family-respectful way? What are the benefits of following the principles of a new model of child-centered care and tools to ensure that children are at the center of hearing care? In this session, we will introduce a conversation guide, My Hearing Explained for Children. My Hearing Explained for Children is a free pediatric tool that helps hearing care professionals empower children and their families to make informed decisions about their hearing care.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.